Louboutin Celine wins
trademark case over red The Parisbased shoemaker sued Yves Saint Laurent in
America last year after it unveiled a design with red soles, a celine trio
bagtraditional feature of Louboutin shoes, which can sell for more than
1,000 a pair. At the time US courts rejected its claim that a single colour
warranted legal protection, but this decision was overturned on appeal by a
panel of three judges yesterday.
The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in New York ruled that celine
phantom the red soles were a "distinctive symbol that qualifies for
trademark celine
classic box bagprotection". However, the ruling only applies to designs
where the red sole is in contrast with the rest of the shoe, so competitors are
free to sell products with a red upper and sole.
David Bernstein, a lawyer for Yves Saint celine mini belt
toteLaurent, labelled the result a victory in a statement to Reuters:
"The Court has conclusively ruled that YSL's monochromatic red shoes do not
infringe any trademark rights of Louboutin, which guarantees that YSL can celine mini
bag continue to make monochromatic shoes in a wide variety of colors,
including red."
Fiona McBride, partner at UK patent and trade mark attorneys Withers Rogers,
said: longawaited celine trapeze
bags outcome of the appeal by Christian Louboutin shows just how hard it
can be to gain protection in relation to the use of a pantone shade of a
specific colour.
instant association of colour http://www.celinehandbagse.com/ with a brand is a lucrative opportunity which
adds value to the brand. However, achieving this recognition and being able to
protect the colour through trade mark registration is celine cabas
phantom not easy. There are high barriers to entry, and as we have seen
in the Louboutin case, success will not provide blanket protection celine tie
bagin relation to a particular colour or shade."
没有评论:
发表评论